The Twisted Guide To The Paranormal, The St. Augustine Lighthouse Haunting Edition
The Haunted Saint Augustine Lighthouse, Florida, USA
On the shoreline of Anastasia Island in Florida, where the Atlantic Ocean meets the mouth of the Matanzas River, the St. Augustine Lighthouse rises above the dunes as one of the most recognizable landmarks along the coast. Completed in 1874, the lighthouse stands about 165 feet tall, its black and white spiral stripes visible for miles across the water. A staircase of 219 iron steps winds upward inside the tower to the lantern room, where the light has guided ships safely along the coastline for more than a century. Nearby stands the keepers’ house, built in 1876, a Victorian style structure with wide porches and tall windows that once served as home to the lighthouse keepers and their families. While the lighthouse is best known for its maritime history, it has also become associated with a number of unusual stories linked to tragedies that occurred during its early years.
One of the most frequently mentioned events involves the daughters of the lighthouse construction superintendent, Hezekiah Pittee. During the early 1870s the tower was still under construction, and workers used a rail cart system to move materials along a track that led toward the water. In July 1873 several children were playing on one of these carts. Among them were Mary Pittee, age fifteen, and Eliza Pittee, age thirteen, along with another child who was visiting. The cart rolled down the track toward the water, but the safety barrier meant to stop it had either been removed or shifted out of place. The cart overturned and fell into the water, trapping the girls beneath it. Workers rushed to lift the cart, but two of the girls drowned before they could be rescued. The tragedy shocked the workers and the Pittee family, and construction on the lighthouse briefly paused while the community mourned the loss.
Over the years stories began to circulate that the spirits of the children might still linger near the lighthouse. Visitors sometimes report hearing laughter or footsteps on the spiral staircase when no one else is present. Others claim to see small shadowy figures moving quickly through the tower or around the grounds. Staff members have occasionally described toys shifting slightly in the keepers’ house museum displays or hearing faint giggling sounds during quiet hours when the building is otherwise empty. These reports have led many people to associate the children who died during construction with the unusual sounds and sightings.
Another historical figure connected to the lighthouse is Joseph Andreu, who served as a keeper at the earlier lighthouse that once stood nearby. In 1859, while painting the tower, Andreu reportedly fell and died during the work. Some visitors claim to smell cigar smoke drifting through the lighthouse or the nearby buildings, even though smoking is not allowed inside. This scent is often attributed in local stories to Andreu, who was known to smoke cigars. A few witnesses have also reported seeing a figure in what appears to be an old style uniform or cap standing near the railing or moving along the tower staircase before disappearing.
Other keepers who worked at the lighthouse over the decades have also become part of its folklore. One name sometimes mentioned is Peter Rasmussen, a lighthouse keeper who lived on the property with his family. Stories connected to him suggest that after the death of his wife he continued his duties quietly at the lighthouse, and later reports of footsteps on the grounds have sometimes been attributed to him in local legend.
The lighthouse has attracted attention from paranormal investigators as well as tourists interested in the stories connected to the site. Television programs and research groups have conducted investigations inside the tower and the keepers’ house, occasionally recording unexplained sounds or fluctuations in electronic equipment. However, skeptics point out that tall structures like lighthouses can create unusual acoustics. Sounds from outside the building may echo through the stairwell, and changes in humidity or electrical conditions can sometimes affect electronic devices used during investigations.
Today the St. Augustine Lighthouse operates as a historic site and museum that welcomes visitors during the day and offers special evening tours that explore both the history and the legends associated with the property. The tower remains a functioning navigational aid, and its beam continues to sweep across the coastline each night. Visitors who climb the long staircase often remark on the atmosphere inside the tower, where the iron steps and narrow passages amplify even the smallest sounds.
Like many historic locations connected to maritime life, the lighthouse carries stories shaped by both documented history and community memory. Accidents during construction and the difficult work performed by lighthouse keepers created events that people continued to talk about long after they occurred. Over time those stories evolved into local legends about the presence of former residents who may still linger in the place where they once lived or worked.
Whether the unusual experiences reported by visitors are the result of natural causes, imagination, or something less easily explained, the St. Augustine Lighthouse remains a powerful symbol of the region’s past. Standing high above the shoreline, it continues to shine across the water just as it has for generations, reminding visitors that places built to guide and protect often hold stories that reach far beyond their original purpose.
Interested In Cryptids, Monsters And Unexplained Creatures? Check Out our Twisted Guide To the Unexplained
About Strange & Twisted
Strange & Twisted is a dark folklore brand and growing online encyclopaedia, the first and only dark lore knowledge database dedicated to cryptozoology, horror, witchcraft, hauntings, true crime, paranormal legends, and unexplained mysteries. Alongside our in depth, research driven articles, we also publish a separate tongue in cheek encyclopaedia that explores the same subjects through dry humour, sarcasm, and observational wit for readers who prefer a lighter, more irreverent take on dark lore.
What makes us unique is in addition to our writing, we create original T shirts, hoodies, and tank tops inspired by the eerie stories we cover. Our goal is to become the internet’s largest hub for horror culture, cryptids, folklore research, ghost stories, and strange apparel, offering both serious scholarship and humour driven storytelling under one unmistakably twisted brand.
Explore The Strange & Twisted Merchandise Store
Shop the Paranormal Investigator T-Shirt
Shop The Ghost Hunter T-Shirt For Paranormal Investigators
Shop The Do You Believe in Ghosts Paranormal T-Shirt
Shop The Paranormal Ouija Board T-Shirt
Shop the Learn To Love Your Poltergeist Paranormal T-Shirt
Shop The Funny Paranormal T-Shirt For Spooky Ghost Fans