The Twisted Guide To The Paranormal, The Great Amherst Mystery Edition
Esther Cox And The Great Amherst Mystery, 1888
In the modest wooden homes of Amherst, Nova Scotia, a small industrial town set along the Tantramar Marshes where the tides of the Bay of Fundy rise and fall with dramatic force, the Teed cottage on Princess Street once stood quietly among rows of similar houses. During the late summer of 1878 this ordinary dwelling became the center of one of Canada’s most famous unexplained cases, later known as the Great Amherst Mystery. For more than a year, beginning in August 1878 and continuing into 1879, the household experienced a series of disturbances that attracted the attention of doctors, ministers, journalists, and curious visitors. The events were witnessed by many people and documented in newspapers across Canada and beyond, yet they have never been fully explained.
The home belonged to Olive Teed and her husband Daniel. Living with them were their two young sons, Daniel’s brother John, and Esther Cox along with her siblings Jennie and William. Esther Cox, who was eighteen years old at the time, soon became the central figure in the strange occurrences. She was described by neighbors as a quiet and somewhat moody young woman. On August 28, 1878, Esther returned home from a buggy ride with a man named Bob MacNeill. According to later accounts, the trip had turned frightening when MacNeill allegedly attempted to assault her. Some reports claim he threatened her with a gun before being interrupted by approaching wagons on the road. Whether every detail of the story is accurate or not, it is clear that Esther returned home extremely shaken and distressed.
Shortly afterward the disturbances in the house began. One evening Esther and her sister Jennie were sharing a bed when they felt something moving beneath the blankets. Esther screamed, believing a mouse had gotten inside the mattress. When the bedding was checked, no animal could be found. Over the following days unusual events continued. Esther’s body sometimes swelled dramatically, particularly around the face and limbs, before returning to normal. Loud knocking sounds began echoing through the walls and floors of the house. Furniture shifted or scraped across the floor without anyone touching it. Household items were reported to move or fly across rooms. On one occasion a bucket overturned by itself, and on another a pillow lifted and struck a visitor.
As the weeks passed the activity seemed to grow stronger. The sounds of knocking became louder and more frequent. Esther’s bed reportedly shook violently while she lay in it. At times she claimed she was lifted or thrown while sleeping. Small fires appeared suddenly around the house when matches were said to ignite without anyone lighting them. Witnesses also described hearing strange voices that spoke in rough or mocking tones, sometimes threatening the household. These events were not limited to nighttime. Neighbors, ministers, and the local physician, Dr. Carritte, claimed to witness some of the disturbances during daylight hours. Objects were seen moving unexpectedly, stones seemed to be thrown from unseen sources, and chairs occasionally overturned on their own.
Dr. Carritte attempted to treat Esther for what he believed might be a nervous condition or some form of physical illness related to stress. When he gave her a sedative to calm her, the disturbances were said by some witnesses to increase rather than decrease. The case soon attracted outside attention. In June 1879 an American actor and investigator named Walter Hubbell arrived in Amherst hoping to prove the events were a hoax. Hubbell stayed in the house for several weeks and kept a diary of everything he observed. Later he published a book titled The Great Amherst Mystery: A True Narrative of the Supernatural.
Hubbell expected to expose trickery, but his published account claimed that he personally witnessed many of the strange events. He described objects moving without visible cause, Esther being pressed down by unseen forces, and unexplained swelling in her body that appeared and disappeared quickly. Hubbell even claimed to communicate with the supposed entity responsible by using knocking sounds to answer yes or no questions. According to his interpretation, the presence identified itself as a spirit or demon that sometimes behaved playfully but often threatened the household.
The disturbances reportedly followed Esther even when she left the Teed home. While staying with friends in other houses, similar events were described, including objects moving and small fires starting unexpectedly. In one instance a nearby barn burned down after earlier threats of fire had been reported during the disturbances. Esther was briefly accused of arson but was eventually released due to lack of evidence.
By late 1879 the strange activity gradually faded away. There was no dramatic confrontation or religious ritual that ended the events. The disturbances simply became less frequent and eventually stopped, particularly after Esther became ill with diphtheria and later recovered.
Over time the case has been examined from many different perspectives. Supporters of the supernatural interpretation argue that the events were witnessed by many respectable members of the community, including doctors and clergy, who could not identify a simple explanation. Skeptics point out that many reported poltergeist cases focus on adolescents experiencing emotional distress, and that the disturbances often occur in environments where stress, trauma, and suggestion are present. Modern interpretations sometimes suggest that Esther’s frightening experience with MacNeill may have caused psychological trauma that manifested in unusual ways within a household already primed by curiosity about spiritualism, which was popular in the late nineteenth century.
The original Teed cottage no longer stands, and the site has long since been replaced by newer buildings in Amherst. Yet the story of Esther Cox and the disturbances that surrounded her remains one of the most famous paranormal cases in Canadian history. It continues to be discussed because it sits at the intersection of psychology, folklore, and the unexplained.
Cases like the Great Amherst Mystery remind us that unusual events often emerge in times of emotional stress and social tension. Witnesses frequently describe disturbances that feel intrusive rather than theatrical, such as unexplained noises, moving objects, or physical sensations that seem impossible to explain at the time. Whether these experiences arise from psychological factors, misinterpretations of natural events, or something still poorly understood, the story of Amherst endures as a reflection of how deeply human experiences, particularly trauma and fear, can shape the way people interpret the world around them.
About Strange & Twisted
Strange & Twisted is a dark folklore brand and growing online encyclopaedia, the first and only dark lore knowledge database dedicated to cryptozoology, horror, witchcraft, hauntings, true crime, paranormal legends, and unexplained mysteries. Alongside our in depth, research driven articles, we also publish a separate tongue in cheek encyclopaedia that explores the same subjects through dry humour, sarcasm, and observational wit for readers who prefer a lighter, more irreverent take on dark lore.
What makes us unique is in addition to our writing, we create original T shirts, hoodies, and tank tops inspired by the eerie stories we cover. Our goal is to become the internet’s largest hub for horror culture, cryptids, folklore research, ghost stories, and strange apparel, offering both serious scholarship and humour driven storytelling under one unmistakably twisted brand.
Explore The Strange & Twisted Merchandise Store
Shop the Paranormal Investigator T-Shirt
Shop The Ghost Hunter T-Shirt For Paranormal Investigators
Shop The Do You Believe in Ghosts Paranormal T-Shirt
Shop The Paranormal Ouija Board T-Shirt
Shop the Learn To Love Your Poltergeist Paranormal T-Shirt
Shop The Funny Paranormal T-Shirt For Spooky Ghost Fans